With article 1, paragraph 48, of Law 207/2024 (2025 budget law) and the subsequent “Bills” Decree (Legislative Decree no. 19/2025) the legislator introduced important innovations regarding the valorisation, for tax purposes and consequently for contribution purposes, of the car benefit granted to employees in mixed use with the aim of simplifying the system but above all of encouraging the use of less pollutants. The Revenue Agency, through circular no. 10 of 3 July 2025, has therefore attempted to clarify the new tax regime applicable to workers who use company vehicles also for personal purposes.
How the benefit is calculated: goodbye to variable percentages
Until 2024, as an exception to the general taxation criterion of benefits in kind based on the “normal value”, the calculation was done on a flat rate basis, taking into account a conventional mileage of 15,000 km per year and the CO₂ emissions of the vehicle. The percentages varied from 25% to 60%, depending on the environmental impact of the vehicle.
With the change made by the Budget Law for 2025, for contracts stipulated starting from 1 January of this year the calculation provides for a fixed percentage of 50% on the annual cost per kilometre, based on the ACI tables. This value represents the theoretical cost of using the vehicle for 15,000 km per year. For vehicles with low environmental impact, such as electric or hybrid ones, reduced rates are foreseen, to encourage more sustainable choices. The new system was introduced by amending article 51, paragraph 4, letter a), of the Consolidated Law on Income Taxes (TUIR).
Joint compliance with the three criteria
The application of the new legislation becomes complicated, however, from the moment in which it is established that the new regulation must be applied if three requirements are jointly respected, namely that the vehicles have been registered from 1 January 2025; have been granted for promiscuous use to employees with
contracts stipulated starting from 1 January 2025; have been assigned (delivered) to employees starting from 1 January 2025. The difficulties in understanding how hybrid cases should be treated with respect to the three criteria pushed the executive to issue the so-called “Bills” decree with the aim of ensuring the progressive implementation of the rule, thus introducing a specific transitional regulation introducing a new case series, namely that of vehicles “ordered by employers by 31 December 2024 and granted in mixed use from 1 January 2025 to 30 June 2025”. The decree therefore allows the application of the previous tax regime even in the event that the vehicle was ordered by the employer by 31 December 2024 and was delivered to the employee from 1 January to 30 June 2025. For the application of the previous regime it is necessary that, in the period between 1 July 2020 and 30 June 2025, the additional requirements of registration and stipulation of the contract. In this regard, the Agency specifies that the assignment of the vehicle requires acceptance by the worker and cannot be resolved with a simple unilateral communication by the employer.
The examples provided by the Agency
The circular uses two examples to clarify to which cases the previous regime applies: in the case of granting a vehicle granted for use with a contract stipulated on 20 December 2024, registered and delivered to the employee in February 2025. Similarly, the previous regime is also applicable to the case in which a vehicle is ordered on 10 July 2024, granted for use with a contract stipulated on 5 February 2025, registered and delivered to the employee in May 2025.
The bugaboo of “normal value” calculation
One of the problems that the Agency has not resolved and which could lead to future disputes on the calculation of the value of “benefits in kind” to be attributed on the payslip is that relating to the calculation of the “normal value” as the tax regime to be attributed in cases not provided for by the new rule and the examples cited. For example, the taxation criterion of the benefits in kind, based on this criterion net of company use, applies in the case of vehicles, ordered by 31 December 2024, granted for mixed use to employees, with contracts stipulated in 2024, registered in 2025 and delivered to the worker in July 2025. In this case, in fact, the transitional regulation cannot be applied as the registration and delivery do not take place by 31 December 2024 and this also applies to the fact that delivery takes place after 30 June 2025 and, equally, the new regulations, introduced by the 2025 budget law, cannot be applied, as the requirements for signing the contract, registration and delivery do not all occur in 2025.
The applicable regimes
In essence, from 2025 there are three possible applicable tax regimes: The new regulations provided for by the 2025 Budget Law will apply to vehicles which, starting from 1 January 2025, are registered, subject to concession contracts for mixed use and delivered to the employee, which consists in the use of the following tax coefficients: 10% in the case of attribution of battery electric vehicles; 20% in case of assignment of plug-in hybrid electric vehicles; 50% in all other cases (methane, LPG, hydrogen, petrol, diesel and Hev hybrid vehicles). The provision in force on 31 December 2024 is applicable to vehicles granted for mixed use until 31 December 2024 and to vehicles ordered by employers by 31 December 2024 and granted for mixed use from 1 January 2025 to 30 June 2025, according to which the taxable amount is determined with the following tax coefficients: 25% for vehicles with Co2 emissions up to 60 g/km; 30% for those between 61 and 160 g/km; 50% for the 161-190 g/km range; 60% for over 190 g/km. The third, and most unfavorable, tax regime is applicable to the remaining cases in which the taxable amount is determined according to the “normal value” of the asset based on Article 9 of the TUIR, i.e. taking as reference, for example, the leasing or rental fee paid by the employer net of the mileage allowance relating to the kilometers traveled for the employer. One criterion could be the difference between the total mileage and the company mileage to be multiplied by the aforementioned leasing fee. If the car is owned by the company, to identify the gross normal value one should still refer to the fees deriving from estimates requested from rental or leasing companies for the same type of model, but we are in the field of hypotheses and, in the absence of a clear and pre-determinable criterion, litigation between employer and worker, as well as between employer and tax authorities, is just around the corner.
