Skip to content
Employment

Pay transparency: equal pay for equal work

interlaced

To avoid the infringement procedure, the Italian State will have to implement the EU Directive 2023/970 on pay transparency by 7 June 2026 and on 5 February the Council of Ministers approved a legislative decree implementing the directive. The approved text, as in the past on other topics, assigns, compared to the directive, a decidedly preponderant role to the National collective labor agreements considered “eligible to guarantee equal pay for the same work or for work of equal value“, where equal value means a different but comparable performance in terms of classification level of the same CCNL.

Directive (EU) 2023/970

According to the EU legislature, greater transparency makes it possible to reveal gender prejudices and discrimination in the remuneration structures of a company or organization, and allows interventions to be adopted to guarantee the application of the right to equal pay for the same work or for work of equal value (right to equal pay). The fundamental principles of the directive are based on pay transparency and on the actors who must monitor its concrete implementation within companies, providing for a consequent enforcement and penalty system. The principle underlying the Directive is that for equal work or work of equal value, the remuneration must be the same.

Pay under the Directive

The directive defines remuneration as“the normal basic or minimum wage or salary and all other benefits paid directly or indirectly, in cash or in kind, by the employer to the worker (additional or variable components) by reason of the latter’s employment”. The directive obliges member states to ensure that companies adopt remuneration systems capable of ensuring equal pay for equal work or work of equal value. To do this, they must provide simple and accessible tools to evaluate jobs in an objective and gender-neutral way. The evaluations are based on criteria such as skills, commitment, responsibility and working conditions, without direct or indirect discrimination. Soft skills should not be underestimated, and each criterion should be weighed according to its relevance to the role. To facilitate especially small businesses, the directive indicates a minimum set of common criteria, such as required training, skills, responsibilities and working conditions.

Implementation in Italy

The draft decree as approved by the Council of Ministers on 5 February provides for the central role of the Ccnl as “pay determination and classification systems based on objective and gender-neutral criteria, suitable for guaranteeing equal pay for the same work or for work of equal value“. In the intentions of the Government, equal pay treatment and transparency is therefore translated into the contractual declarations of collective bargaining considered a meeting point of employer and trade union needs. Although not fully compliant with the dictates of the directive because it omits those additional individual remuneration elements that the directive cites in its definition of remuneration, the draft decree remedies this by providing in paragraph 4 of article 4 that the “salary levels” of the collective bargaining agreements can be integrated translating the company practices with which elements, rewards and benefits are normally recognized “ad personam” into policies or regulations and “provided that they are characterized by objective and gender-neutral criteriaHowever, the parliamentary commissions are focusing on the draft decree, in particular on the issue of the “salary level” as the point of greatest tension between the political forces.

Employers covered by the rules

The European directive provides for a system of obligations that does not apply in the same way to all companies. The European legislator, in fact, while guaranteeing workers’ right to equal pay, wanted to avoid micro and small companies being burdened by excessive obligations. For this reason, the regulatory framework is based on a simple principle: all employers are subject to the principles of transparency, but the concrete obligations vary based on the number of employees. It is recognized that businesses of up to 100 employees who may be disproportionately affected by new administrative burdens, should not be treated in the same way as large businesses. In this context, the rules introduced can be summarized in four broad categories: transparency in personnel selection, clarity on economic progression criteria, workers’ right to know the average salary levels in positions of equal value, reporting obligations on the gender pay gap.

Employer obligations

Transparency in the selection phase concerns all companies, therefore, each employer must communicate to candidates the starting salary (or the range corresponding to the position), based on objective and gender-neutral criteria. Furthermore, it is no longer possible to ask for information on wages received in previous employment relationships. Other obligations, however, change significantly depending on the size of the company. The most structured companies will have to provide reporting regarding the overall gender pay gap, gender pay gap in complementary or variable components, median gender pay gap, median gender pay gap in complementary or variable components,     percentage of female and male workers who receive complementary or variable components, percentage of female and male workers in each pay quartile, gender pay gap by categories of workers, divided between normal basic salary or salary and complementary or variable components.

For these obligations, the timing includes, for companies with over 250 employees, the annual report with the “dead line” at 7 June 2027; from 2027 those in the 150-249 employee range will also be involved with reporting every three years and those in the 100-149 employee range starting from 2031. As regards transparency on the economic progression criteria, the implementing decree provides that companies with fewer than 50 employees are exempt from the obligation to make these criteria public in a structured form. A further differential treatment concerns the right of workers to obtain information on the average salary levels of people doing the same work or work of equal value. To prevent this information from making individual employees identifiable in very small companies, companies with fewer than 50 employees will be able to provide this data by publishing information on the average salary levels, broken down by sex, of the categories of workers carrying out the same job or work of equal value on their intranet or in the reserved area of ​​the company website. Finally, the obligation with the greatest organizational impact, namely transparency on the corporate gender pay gap, is triggered only for medium-large sized companies, therefore companies with at least 100 employees. Smaller companies, therefore, will not have to carry out periodic reporting on the gender pay gap.