Skip to content
Employment

Stressful working environments and compensation for damages

interlaced

The term mobbing comes from the English verb “to mob”, which translates into Italian as “to crowd around, crowd or crowd around, surround”, or “attack, assault” referring to a group of people. These are behaviors of individuals engaged in actions aimed at hitting a specific target. In jurisprudence, the term mobbing has identified a set of vexatious, repeated and long-lasting conduct, both individual and collective, which, if directed against a worker by hierarchical superiors, is also called “bossing” and has the intent to oust the individual from the working environment, when instead it is carried out by colleagues, the aim is to isolate and alienate the individual from the common working context and in this case we speak of horizontal mobbing.

The Constitutional Court

The Constitutional Court with sentence 10-19 December 2003, n. 359, outlined a precise legal framework of the phenomenon, defining it as “complex” and “consisting of a series of oppressive acts or behaviors, prolonged over time, carried out against a worker by the members of the work group in which he or she is included or by his/her boss, characterized by an intent to persecute and marginalize aimed at the primary objective of excluding the victim from the group. This implies the existence of one or more active subjects to whom the aforementioned behaviors can be attributed and of a passive subject who is the recipient and victim of such behaviors”.

According to the Court, these are behaviors of compulsion but also simply of omission which can be expressed both in actual legal acts and in simple material behaviors having in any case, both, the double peculiarity of being able to be, if examined individually, also lawful, legitimate or irrelevant from a legal point of view, but which acquire, in any case, importance as characterizing elements of the overall conduct which has the aim of persecution and marginalization of the subject.

The consequences

These are actions that can lead to the onset of various types of disorders in the recipient involving the psychological, physical, behavioral, social and professional spheres, for example among those with the most serious consequences: posttraumatic stress syndrome, generalized anxiety and panic attacks, but also sleep disorders, cardiovascular diseases, changes in eating behavior or abuse of alcohol or drugs. Jurisprudence traces the various types of mobbing to the provisions of Article 2087 c.c. which prescribes an obligation on the employer to adopt the measures necessary to protect the physical integrity and moral personality of the workers when carrying out the business. This is the precept on which the employer’s contractual responsibility is based. In recent years, precisely on the basis of this linking of the phenomenon to the broader concept of protection of the worker’s health, multiple disputes have therefore arisen, aimed no longer or not only at the compensation action against the employer, but also at the request for Inail compensation protection as an occupational disease.

The Supreme Court and workplace “straining”

In the Italian working and legal context, the term has been adopted to indicate a situation of psychological pressure or stress on the worker which produces long-lasting and negative effects on health or the working environment. Therefore, while in English the term can refer generically to a physical or mental effort, in Italian employment law it has taken on a technical meaning linked to the employer’s responsibility for harmful working environments. The novelty on the matter is the order of the Cassation n. 123/2025 on the basis of which it was established that, even in the absence of mobbing, the employer can be held responsible if it allows the persistence of a stressful environment that damages the worker’s health. This is an ordinance that marks further progress in the definition of employer responsibility with respect to work conflicts and stressful conditions. While excluding the possibility of mobbing and straining in the absence of persecutory intent, the ruling clarifies that the employer can still respond exArticle 2087 c.c.if he allows, even negligently, the maintenance of a harmful and stressful working environment. In particular, the Supreme Court recognizes the legal relevance of the stress deriving from conflict at work, affirming the importance of protecting even the most fragile workers: the greater vulnerability of the employee increases, rather than attenuates, the employer’s obligations of protection.

The Court’s reasoning

The case arises from the legal action of a worker who asked to ascertain the mobbing she allegedly suffered in the context of a reorganization of her company. The Court of Appeal considered that the reorganization choice of the company involving the appellant was not unreasonable and had, instead, been adequately motivated by the employer, but considered, however, that the conflict of the personal relationships existing within the office to which the appellant was employed would have required the employer to adopt appropriate measures to restore the serenity necessary for the correct performance of work duties, including possibly the use of disciplinary power. The employer can, therefore, be held responsible for straining as an attenuated form of mobbing for stressful behaviours, even in the absence of a plurality of oppressive actions, if harmful effects are still produced for the interested party.

Litigation

A sentence which essentially condemns the employer for not having adopted disciplinary measures to quell disagreements in the work environment, but which also led to the opposite effect. The legal dispute we are experiencing following sentence no. 123/2025, in fact, now does not focus only on the legitimacy of the disciplinary action itself (when and if adopted by the employer), but rather on the need for the employer to defend itself from the opposing theory, according to which the procedure adopted would have generated a stressful environment such as to compromise the psycho-physical health of the employee.

A change of direction

With the ordinance of n. 14890 of 3 June 2025, the Supreme Court sets things right and establishes, in a similar case, that there was no stressful purpose knowingly implemented towards the workers, in a reorganization aimed at improving the management of the company and the achievement of more consistent sales performances, thus rejecting the requests for compensation for damages and excluding that the company’s conduct could constitute the extremes of “straining” or “mobbing”. As always, evaluations must therefore be made on a case-by-case basis.